Wednesday, February 21, 2018

Post 2, Group A (Resubmission): Full Metal Jacket: A Narrative on Suicide

   Stanley Kubrick's 1987 Vietnam War classic Full Metal Jacket was one of many films of the era to tackle the conflict in Southeast Asia. This film manages to stand out, however, for several reasons. There are the painfully slow, agonizing combat scenes. Kubrick also presents a stark examination of American Imperialism. I believe, however, that the success of the film hinges on its unique portrayal of a particular setting and story.
   Kubrick essentially made two movies. One about his characters shedding their youthful innocence and becoming trained killers, and all of the psychological and physical burdens they must bare throughout this transformation. Another about the trauma and destruction of warfare, and the moral conflictions of the soldiers. We will focus on the first half of the film, undoubtedly the most recognizable portion.
   The setting is Boot Camp. Combat training is not often depicted in war films, and even more rarely to such an extent. A mixture of bright-eyed, eager enlistees and apprehensive and fearful draftees are thrown into the fire, subject to both physical and mental conditioning. The hard edged drill instructor, Sergeant Hartman, is one of cinema's most memorable characters. The scenes with the actor and veteran R. Lee Ermey ripping his recruits hearts apart with wildly creative insults are what most people recall about this film. This constant degradation, paired with the physical fatigue of military schedules and conditioning makes for a nightmarish environment that drives one recruit, Private Leonard Lawrence, past his breaking point.

   This is where we will transition from setting to story. Private Lawrence, played by Vincent D'Onofrio, is a large man with a low level of intelligence. This leads to a series of mistakes, and creative insults and punishments from Sergeant Hartman. This cycle begins to have a noticeable impact on Lawrence's behavior. The constant berating and physical punishment begin to make him distant amd self loathsome. He is at one point nick named Gomer Pyle, on account of his inability to follow instruction consistently. This verbal abuse only aids in his alienation.
   After hiding a jelly donut in his footlocker and being caught by Sergeant Hartman, Lawrence is forced to watch his squad mates do push-ups as punishment for his indiscretion. This method of punishing the group becomes Sergeant Hartman's preferred method of punishing Lawrence.
We take a break from the film here to consult an article from the Journal of Clinical Psychology from 2010 by Craig Bryan, Kelly Cukrowicz, Christopher West, and Chad Morrow entitled "Combat Experience and the Acquired Capability for Suicide." We learn here of psychologist Thomas Joiner's Interpersonal-Psychological Theory of Suicidal Behavior. This theory consists of three variables, but for now we'll restrict our focus to the first two. These are perceived burdensomeness and thwarted belongingness. Perceived burdensomeness, as described by our authors, is, "the sense that the individual is a burden to others, does not contribute to the group, and is a liability to the group's well-being or safety." (pg. 1045) Thwarted belongingness is defined as, "the sense that the individual lacks important connections to others and that previously meaningful relationships have been strained or lost." (pg. 1045)
   All three variables are said to need to be present for an individual to take their own life. These first two refer to the development of the motivation to do so, and speak to the construction of suicidal thoughts. When referring to the story of Private Lawrence we can see the slow and arduous development of these two variables.
   The punitive practices of Sergeant Hartman, such as forcing Lawrence to eat the donut while his comrades were punished, served to reinforce a feeling of isolation and lack of unity for Lawrence. Lawrence was already beginning to feel like a burden to the team, due to his inability to complete tasks properly, if at all. This is his percieved burdensomeness.
  One scene depicts the unit beating Lawrence in his sleep with bars of soap wrapped in socks. Not only did the unit as a whole make it clear how much of an outsider he was, his only ally, James "Joker" Davis, also participated. Lawrence now feels the sense of thwarted belongingness.
We can see pretty clearly Lawrence's budding motivations for committing suicide to escape the tortures and trauma of training. But what is there to say regarding the capacity to carry out this fearful action? This is where we encounter Joiner's third variable. After percieved burdensomeness and thwarted belongingness take hold, this individual can gain what Joiner calls the acquired capability for suicide. This is, "the degree to which an individual is able to enact a lethal suicide attempt." (pg. 1045)
   The violence enacted upon Lawrence by his peers, superiors, and the training itself desensitized him so much to the thought of death that he acquired this suicidal capability. His only proficiency throughout his training, marksmanship, instilled the confidence to commit such an act. As our authors state, "Because a lethal or near-lethal suicide attempt is extremely fear-inducing and often pain-inducing, habituation to the fear and pain involved is a prerequisite for serious suicidal behavior." (pg. 1045)
   Lawrence's training and abuse broke down his fear of death or pain, and his abilities with a firearm gave him a tool.

 Kubrick documented a maddening and frightful descent into madness, and ultimately death. Private Lawrence is found by Joker in the latrine late one night just before deployment to Vietnam. There he finds Lawrence with an assault rifle, loading the magazine, referencing the ammunition type that lends its name to film's title. Lawrence kills his tormentor, Sergeant Hartman before turning the weapon on himself.
   Private Leonard Lawrence was shown to have exhibited all three of Joiner's variables for suicide. This depiction is raw and apparent. Set against the backdrop of military combat training , the story finds unique footing in the genre, making Full Metal Jacket a timeless war classic.

6 comments:

  1. When I was around 13 I saw my dad watching this movie, and I wanted to watch it with him but he told me no. I believe the suicide scene was the reason he didn't want me to see. Years later when I was watching on my on, I found this scene really disturbing and sad, thinking back I think I had some very vivid nightmares about it at the time. I just couldn't help but feel sorry for Private Pyle because no matter how hard he tried he never could do things correctly, and I have definitely felt like that before.
    -Carter

    ReplyDelete
  2. This post was well written and flowed extremely well. I could not stop reading. Suicide is and shall continue to be a strong issue within our society. I have actually never seen this movie, but your description of the toll of military training that the film expresses makes me want to delve into it. One thing that stood out to me was the third variable of Joiner's theory, "the degree to which an individual is able to enact a lethal suicide attempt." Your point was that Private Lawrence's military training gave him both the ability to kill and broke down his fear of death and pain. My question is, outside of the military what are some examples of this theory holding true? Another question I have is, do situations of suicide happen where people are in the opposite situation, as they are one of the leaders of a group and are seemingly loved by everyone? I would argue yes. Even though they are not an outcast, they instead of the pressure of the hopes of those they are leading. This burden of leadership can cause the same build up, but rather than being made into an outsider as a result of being incapable, pressure from the fear of failure builds on the mind of a leader thus leading to the same ending. Death has been and shall continue to be the leading first solution to pain and failure in the minds of everyone. It does not matter what position a person holds in life if their only thought is to rid themselves of their pain or failure, then death is perceived to be the only option.
    -Alan Donoho

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wow, I have never seen this movie but it definitely sounds intense. It sounds like it gets to really emotional and important themes about war- the destruction of boyhood, trauma of training and violence. It's interesting how you analyzed the character alongside Joiner's theory. I think it brings up good signs to look for to recognize when someone might be at risk of committing suicide. Overall, though, I appreciate how this film seems to go into more than the honor and respect of war. In my opinion war brings out awful traits of humanity and it has a damaging impact on the soldiers. So it's interesting to read about the aftermath of this, especially because it's focused on the training. Like you said, not many movies focus on the training part.
    - Bailey

    ReplyDelete
  4. Watching this movie for the first time can be an intense experience for anyone at any age. The way you described the plot of the movie and tied in your article were very well executed. The topic you picked is and forever will be a tragic experience had by all. However, delving deeper into the psyche of potential suicidal promisees is very interesting and to hear about the cycle of the down ward spiral is something that should be studied more. I would be interested in reading about the damaging effects of boot-camp on the psyche of soldiers by doing studies before and after there time in basic training.
    Very, very well written.
    Kyle Gardner

    ReplyDelete
  5. Watching this movie for the first time can be an intense experience for anyone at any age. The way you described the plot of the movie and tied in your article were very well executed. The topic you picked is and forever will be a tragic experience had by all. However, delving deeper into the psyche of potential suicidal promisees is very interesting and to hear about the cycle of the down ward spiral is something that should be studied more. I would be interested in reading about the damaging effects of boot-camp on the psyche of soldiers by doing studies before and after there time in basic training.
    Very, very well written.
    Kyle Gardner

    ReplyDelete
  6. Although this a movie, I was told that the scene at the beginning was a semi real event. The actor shown in the picture that made that part of the movie so significant was an actual high ranking militant. He took the place of the original actor that was suppose to perform that part. His original job was to coach the actor in order to give an as real as possible scene as possible. That scene was actually him demonstrating how he wanted that actor to perform. The producer liked it so much, he decided to retain the improve. My point is that these guys undergo extensive amounts of mental hardships to achieve beast-like heart. I guess that this is to help create a solider better suited for combat. On the other hand, we all maintain the person that we were raised to be and it is difficult to change that. I believe that some solders grow a passion for his or her military duties and are willing do what ever it takes to accomplish that. They are mentally broken down and brought to a state where is becomes difficult to control.

    -Rob D

    ReplyDelete

Resubmissios Essay

Throughout this essay I will be discussing the skills that I need to work on with it being personal skills and skills that pert...