Tuesday, March 6, 2018

Post 2 Group C: Inequality and socialism represented within the education system within Low income Area's: Drop Out Nation, By: Montaya Mccloud



We have a lot of Modern social issues in society that need to be overcome. Drugs, violence and peer pressure are extreme concepts that most young adults encounter throughout life. There are important issues that should be discussed, and several people that deserved to be educated on them.  Recently I watched a documentary on PBS, that was very informant. The film was called Dropout Nation in which they had several children they recorded from a school in Houston (PBS). The children didn’t live in stable homes or have a normal family life and were all minorities. The children had many obstacles to go through outside of school. One boy was in their streets, had anger issues, and smoked weed. Also, there was a girl name sparkle who had a kid, no home, and her mom passed away prior (pbs). The school was a low-income school in which I was able to see how unequal funding based on property taxes, violence, and dropping out affected the school’s education. The problems were described as problems associated with upbringing, family issues, and education. As Stated by Kenneth Langone, “You want to close the income inequality gap in part? Give us better educated kids out of high school. Give us kids that can challenge and succeed in the challenge with technology. You give us those kinds of kids and watch the needle move”. I believe the producer had good intentions while creating the documentary, but I believe the students were overly shown in a negative perspective. I believe the producer over exaggerated their problems and actions which is not ok. In the film Drop out Nation only lower-income Minority students were recorded, and there where not any scenes shown of them having acceptable behavior in the community or school.




The problem with this Film  based on African americans in poverty is that it leaves viewers especially people of color vulnerable to harmful biases and stereotypes. There are several theories behind why African americans are in the situations they reside within Society’s Lower Social Class. The famous theories reach back to the mid 1800’s. Dysaethesia Aethiopic was sought to be an illness that only African americans had. The disorder was a mental illness which was believed to be the reason why African Americans were lazy (Cartwright). In 1851, Carwright suggest that “There is a partial insensibility of the skin, and so great a hebetude of the intellectual faculties, as to be like a person half asleep, that is with difficulty aroused and kept awake. It is much more prevalent among free negroes living in clusters by themselves, than among slaves on our plantations, and attacks only such slaves as live like free negroes in regard to diet, drinks, exercise, etc. The disease is the natural offspring of negro liberty--the liberty to be idle, to wallow in filth, and to indulge in improper food and drinks”(Cartwright).  The American physician Cartwright believed that Dysaethesia Aethiopic was a disease that could biologically be passed through African Americans. The documentary shows the ideal that all minorities in a low income class have horrible homes and no supportive family members. The film portrays a sense of learned behavior passed down from unstable parents directly to children. Growing up i went to a 100% african american school in a low income area called Hogan Preparatory Academy, in which all students didn't have the same Homefront problems  shown in this documentary.As Stated by Victoria Osteen, "I think that we have a great opportunity to impart our wisdom and our knowledge and our experience to this younger generation. it may be different times, but experience transcends time, and wisdom transcends time". I believe it is very important that we encourage and help the youth in the community. The next generation are responsible for taking care of us as we grow old, the economy, and the condition the legacy we leave behind lives in.The Film Drop Out Nation should have been produced in a less stereotypical way, there are important issues that should be discussed about lower income areas, and several people that deserved to be educated on them. 

PBS. "Dropout nation." n.d. frontline .<http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/dropout-nation/>.

serva, Christene. "Study.com." n.d. Lactent function is sociology.<https://study.com/academy/lesson/latent-functions-in-sociology-lesson-quiz.html>.
Cartwright, Dr. Samuel A. Diseases and Peculiarities of the Negro Race. Volume XI. Debow's Review . New York: AMS Press, Inc. , 1851.


13 comments:

  1. The parts that I agree was having lots of Modern social issues in society. For example, in this generation, more teenage girls out there ends up having babies at a very young age. For me, I would say to all the teenage girls out there; they cannot raise a child of their own. They are still a child themselves. Since adolescent girls have kids, they’re either going to be on their own, taking care of their baby or send them to foster care. It’s their choice of what they think it is best for their child, but if they are thinking about making an abortion, I don’t think so, and I don’t believe that is going to work. It’s like, you are killing your unborn child. To be honest, I don’t believe in abortion.

    -Kendra ZeMenye

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also believe that our students deserve a better education. In high school I saw an emphasis on subjects like math and science, while things like art and music classes, are being seen as more of an extra-curricular activity rather than something that can really improve a students intelligence and performance in other subjects. PBS actually has an article I will post below that talks about the different benefits of having some form of music lessons. Some of these benefits being; better language skills, an increased IQ, and improved test scores. One thing I found it didn't mention in great detail is the emotional aspect of music, it is an amazing outlet for your anxieties. This I feel it is crucial that our students learn about music, and our education system would improve with more focus on music.
    -Carter Messner

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. http://www.pbs.org/parents/education/music-arts/the-benefits-of-music-education/

      Delete
  3. I believe a lot of these communities are still reeling from many of the racist housing legislation in the wake of the great depression as well as the general apathetic attitude the government tends to have towards the plight of racial minorities, those of which tending to be more concentrated in inner city and urban areas. This compounded upon the fact that because of how dilapidated the aforementioned places have become over time, which has lead to them become hot beds for criminal activity; has and is working as a major deterrent for people who would like to assist in the rebuilding of these area. So I think there are many aspects of this that need to be addressed in the US and that the high school drop out issue is more so just symptomatic of larger social inequities that are being dealt with just very slowly.

    -Kenneth

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think that a large issue with the current dropout rate is the underfunding of inner city schools. Without the intervention of the government, these schools get worse and so run down that: 1. decent teachers don't want to work there because they won't get paid well, 2. Kids don't receive the same education as well funded state schools. Just as you said in your post, give the schools the finds they need to get the struggling kids education they need, and watch how these kids adapt to life beyond high school. As just a general note, there are a few minor spelling and punctuation mistakes that you have.
    Besides that, a really informative post.
    - Kyle Gardner

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have been aware of what one would call the "achievement gap" for a number of years. When I was first informed on the allocation of funds as it relates to public schools, I was shocked to say the least! I find it inhumane to render a child a "skewed" education because of the community that they were simply born into. Something has to be done about the inequality of our education system and things such as these documentary are great starts to a proactive change.

    -Kyra Moore

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great post. It is interesting, I've always felt that adequate schooling for all citizens is actually a very capitalistic concept. Within capitalism (and all economics, for that matter), it is recognized that there are three aspects to an economy: land, labor, and capital. While it seems like capitalism's goal is to make rich people richer, I've always felt that capitalism's goal should be an efficient economy that creates and allocates resources fairly and effectively. If you want to maximize the potential of the American economy, you have to make sure that every citizen has equal access to quality education, healthcare, and opportunity. This maximizes the effectiveness of your work force. The argument for adequate schooling and healthcare isn't just an emotional argument based on the fact that there are kids suffering, it is also a common sense argument based in economics. This leaves you with a question: if the argument for adequate schooling and healthcare is so obvious, why is it still an issue? I think it comes down to greed and a regression towards aristocratarianism - the ones who have the highest opportunity to succeed are the ones who come from successful families. Anyways, great post and thanks for sharing!

    -JJ

    ReplyDelete
  7. I enjoyed your overall presentation of the documentary you chose, but I had several questions regarding certain parts of the latter half of your post. What are the latent functions you spoke of at the start of the second paragraph so that we readers have the context you would want us to have? Is there a socialist conflict theory that is different from sociology's? Also where is the information you got from your cited source exactly?

    --Zach

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great post! After viewing this post, I am going to find this documentary and watch it! I agree with you when you state that we, as in a society, should improve on our education in low-income areas. In parallel, I play both sides of the spectrum. The other side is the fact that in most low-income educational systems lack the transfer of information in order to improve the minds of the children with in the community. Just to name a few, this information consists of advancements in technology, profession types, and generational opportunities. This results in children that will have lower confidence and is extremely important in education. As a result, the finances and in the interest is not and probably will never be there.

    -Rob D

    ReplyDelete
  9. Montoya,

    I genuinely enjoy your topic and film! I found conflict to be really interesting especially when it meddles with access to education resources and crime. While I do thing that conflict theory is important and can be effective in certain situation, it has been discovered that a variety of resources and theories in place created specifically for different communities have the capabilities to work well. You also touch on equal education economics. While I do agree that all students deserve a good and equal quality of education, we must focus on where the funding is coming from. A majority of it comes from property taxes. Low income areas do not have the necessary income from property taxes to provide better educational resources to the students. While taxes are important so is voter turnout and it is well known that voter turnout is increasingly low in low income communities.

    -Aly Hernandez

    ReplyDelete
  10. I really found your post really interesting. Even though I haven't heard of the Apollo 20 program before it sounds very important and productive program. There are so many kids out there who have a big struggle with math and science and having such kind of program would solve and lower the problems. I also believe there should be equal opportunity for all citizen regardless the financial background since education is the foundation of developing a country. I really like the idea you brought up on your post. Great job!

    -Weini W.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Growing up in southern California and then moving to a more affluent town in Missouri the changes between educational systems was huge. In California, our school was very policed, we had to wear uniforms, go through security systems in elementary school. We had no PE class, music class, and no playground—it was all just very bare minimum. Our educational system was ineffective because of the low income area. Then I moved into a small town in Missouri and I saw a huge change. It was weird to see separate schools for certain grades because back in Cali we all went to the same school K-12. Here there was an elementary school, middle school, etc. In HS, I received multiple opportunities I know I wouldn’t have received in LA. It’s crazy to think about where my life would’ve been if I had stayed in Cali, but it’s even crazier to think about how many people are still stuck there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry, this is Kathleen Paxtor. I forgot to put my name

      Delete

Resubmissios Essay

Throughout this essay I will be discussing the skills that I need to work on with it being personal skills and skills that pert...