Tuesday, March 13, 2018

Post 3 Group A: Race as a Dollar Sign by Aly Hernandez


The Bronx Slave Market by Marvel Cooke introduced the topic of racial controversial discourse prevalent before the 1900s, during the 1950s, and significantly present in our day and age. Many who fail to understand the intricate weaving's of American racism often ask themselves “Why is racism even a conversation anymore? With all the programs such as affirmative action in place to help minorities assimilate, why are we still talking about racism?” The question I pose and attempt to answer in this post is this: “Why is The Bronx Slave Market just as important now as it was in the 1950s”?

Here we go…

First, I would like to bring up a book I read a few years ago, The Other Wes Moore by Wes Moore. This book attempts to address a serious problem in African-American youths - the disproportionately high amount of poverty and crime afflicting black communities. How could two people by the same name, from similar backgrounds and neighborhoods, born within a few years from each other grow to have two completely different lives from one another. One is a Rhodes Scholar the other is in prison for murder other crimes. In one of my favorite quotes throughout the book, Wes Moore writes, “This book is meant to show how, for those of us who live in the most precarious places in this country, our destinies can be determined by a single stumble down the wrong path, or a tentative step down the right one.” In this, Moore seeks to provide his readers with an essential life lesson of precaution and awareness. By reading his book, experiencing his life and the other Wes Moore’s life, the reader is already taking measures into taking a step down the right path, but that is easier said than done. Although Moore does provide the readers with an abundance of resources to help in the end of his book, the choice to do better is often a difficult one than imagined. It is difficult because while we all hate to admit it, money is the fruit to our success in this country. You either have it or you don’t and if you don’t you have to find a way to get it. The American dream is drilled into us and our ideas of success. The means to success are too often difficult for some to obtain. Crime is often committed in the absence of money and providing for the necessities in life often proves to be a challenge for a disproportionate number of minorities.

The same ailments that plague the lives of many impoverished African-American youth affected the women of the “Paper Bag Brigade”. They too worked for a lower wage than the minimum wage, often working below their means; after all some money is better than no money. When jobs ran low, what then? One of the fears that Cooke had for the women of the “Paper Bag Brigade” was not that they would work for less than the value of their performance and worth, but that they would succumb to prostitution. Is this not a similar situation in which many minorities such as The Other Wes Moore find themselves? Again, this is simple survival trying to make it paycheck by paycheck. The Bronx Slave market still exits re-branded under a different face known as the mass incarcerations of African-Americans. Bruce Western and Christopher Wildeman write that “Age, race, and educational disparities concentrate imprisonment among the disadvantaged. Figure 3 shows trends in incarceration rates for young black and white men with different levels of schooling”.  That graph demonstrates the contrast between white and black incarcerations based on levels of education. It is important because while we are having the highest incarcerations, a large portion of our incarcerations are blacks. This is the new American slave market where prisons are literally getting funded by the number of inmates they can get. The motto goes that the darker the inmate is the larger the cash flow and such as system is revolting and sickening.

They take their labor, pay them next to nothing, take their liberty, and their hope for a brighter future. When it gets tough it becomes easier for the children of minorities, the children of immigrants, and the children of poverty, to enlist the help and benefits of the criminalized path to success.
So then…Why is racism still important?

Because it makes white people uncomfortable. We live in a system that steadily gives resources to white people at the complete expense of African Americans. The system that takes their labor, their thoughts, their culture, their rights, their freedom, and their music to re-brand to give to white communities. Almost identical to the Bronx Slave Market where the women were stripped of their labor, their freedom, their thoughts, and their rights. You cannot move on from the past until the same group that is being oppressed is given the necessary resources to assimilate and prosper without fear of any kind of reprisal from others who feel threatened. It is important because a large group of people are being incarcerated and used for money and it is not okay.


10 comments:

  1. I completely agree with everything you've said in your post. It really is upsetting that it is a known and proven fact that African Americans are arrested and imprisoned more often than White people for doing the same crimes.... or should I say, "crimes". Another thing that is extremely upsetting is that the things that are getting these people arrested and imprisoned are often not really "bad" enough for the punishments. Minor thefts and drug possession should not be on the same level (or even sometimes more punishable if you are black) than things like rape and murder.

    Jared Islas

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm glad you did a blog post over this piece. I think this article and the conversations we had in class were pretty important and eye-opening. I don't think that racism or oppression has gone away at all, it just wears different masks. There are still minorities working in awful conditions for very low pay. And as you mentioned, mass incarceration is a problem in America as the prisoners are exploited and the prisons are for-profit. I get frustrated when people deny that racism still exists, because it still does. It's all around us. It can be hard to recognize if you come from a white background that isn't exposed to many problems of minorities, but that's why talking to each other and learning is so important.
    -Bailey West

    ReplyDelete
  3. I completely agree! Racism is still a huge issue in today's society. It simply has morphed to pass under the radar. Racism is different to what it was back then but it has never gone away. It holds the same purpose to degrade and discriminate other human beings due to their race. It is also extremely upsetting that more prisons are being built as opposed to schools. Imprisonment seems to be valued much more the education. In addition, the U.S. spends a great sum of money to operate these facilities. The government needs to do something about it because it is evidently not right.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am glad that you brought the topic that we discussed in class in your blog post. Racism in the 60s was different from what we have right now. Racism is truly showing its unpleasant face on just about every level in our society. We are seeing the president of the United States making racist comments toward African-Americans, Hispanics, Muslims and people from third world countries. I agree with what you pointed regarding the mass incarcerations of African-Americans. It is sad that those things are still happening. This all need to change.

    -Weini W.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with everything you said in your blog post, I think you really do capture one of our biggest issues well. The book “The Other Wes Moore” reminded of a conversation that I had with one of my friends a while back. We were talking about our parents and how they immigrated here and adapted. Her dad as soon as he got older decided to give up his Hispanic culture to be able to achieve something in the US whereas my father did not. Both men had “equal” opportunities to get to where they are at in life now they just took two completely different roads to get there.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great post, I really enjoyed reading it. I agree with nearly everything you wrote. I do however disagree that racism is important today because it makes white people uncomfortable. I'm not sure that I follow what you mean by that. From what I have seen, racism is important today because of the systems created when racism was incredibly prevalent in the US. For example, data is biased today against minority communities in regard to crime statistics because of outright racism from decades ago. Through what was called "predicative policing", heightened police presence were put in communities that were thought to have a higher likelihood of crime occurring. This system was put in place when the country was much more racist, so black and Hispanic communities were heavily targeted. This created a positive feedback loop. If you heighten the police force in an area, you are going to get more arrests. Black and Hispanic communities don't smoke more weed than white communities, but black and Hispanic communities are more likely to get searched because of data analytics. This feedback loop has caused the statistics of minority crime to be skewed, and this is data that we still use today to observe behavior amongst communities. This is why I think racism is so hard to talk about today. The average American is far less racist today than the average American 100 years ago. For the most part, I would say most people don't hate people of other races just because they are another race. So how do you convince someone who isn't racist that racism from 50 years ago is still oppressing minorities? It is difficult and takes a lot of discussion. I think that this is why "The Bronx Slave Market" is so important to revisit. If we want to address the systematic oppression of minorities today, we have to understand the outright racism and oppression of minorities yesterday. This is of course my white, straight male point of view, so take it with a grain of salt.

    -JJ

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. JJ,

      Thank you for your thoughts! I would say that by "it makes white people uncomfortable" I am referring to the fact that whites talk around the subject of racism but never about it. I probably should have expanded on that in my post. I would argue that its not that people are less racist today than they were 50 years ago, but that what we view as racist has evolved since the 50s and has taken a highly seclusive shape and form. As for the heightened areas of hot spotting in densely populated minority areas, I would agree with your statistical loop. A key example of that is the practice of "stop and Frisk" as a crime control method instead of a standard policing practice. It was not meant to target minorities, but the data reflected otherwise.

      Again thank you for your thoughts!

      -Aly Hernandez

      Delete
  7. This as a really good post! I agree the a lot of what you said but to speak to the sentiment of racism being uncomfortable for white people to talk about today, I think that just has to do with what it means and looks like in today's society. I think because we've made so much progress with race relations in the wake of the end of slavery and civil at (generally speaking) and because for the most part it really isn't socially acceptable to be outwardly racist(the obvious exclusions being spaces designed explicitly for that), most white people probably believe that they harbor no discriminatory racial biases, so being told that they might would likely (and understandably) put them on the defensive. In the same way that if you fancied yourself to be a good speaker and someone said you weren't your initial reaction might be to stand your ground and try to prove to them why they're wrong, and justifiably so. Granted this is just a theory and I could be over generalizing or just wholesale wrong because it is coming from personal experiences, but it's just food for thought.

    -Kenneth

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with everything you say, and you are 100% right. All I know is, racism is never going away. Plus, people are never going to let go of the past of how racism starts in centuries. It is human nature to trust those we identify with more. So when those times come of disagreement and conflict, the race will more easily become involved, if it can become involved. For example, African Americans got treated differently from white people. They got mistreated equally. Martin Luther King decides to changed it and led to non- violence protests against the segregation. Doing this was very dangerous though, he got arrested, and his house got bombed. That is why racism is wrong.

    -Kendra ZeMenye

    ReplyDelete

Resubmissios Essay

Throughout this essay I will be discussing the skills that I need to work on with it being personal skills and skills that pert...